Adrian Lewis has struck a nerve with his comments about the standard at the top of darts today. The two-time world champion told Online Darts that the competition was considerably stronger 15 years ago than it is now, saying: "I don't think Luke Littler and Luke Humphries are playing against the same kind of caliber that we were playing against. I really don't. I think probably 10 or 15 years ago I think we still had a better top 10 in the world rankings." That is a bold claim in the era of Littler and Humphries, but the numbers make the debate more interesting than you might expect.
A comparison between today's world top 10 and the rankings in 2015 reveals a striking difference in the number of major titles won. The current top ten have won 51 major titles between them, while the top ten from eleven years ago had no fewer than 163 majors to their names. Yet that gap tells only part of the story. One key reason for the difference is Phil Taylor's place in the 2015 top ten – the darts legend won an incredible 79 major titles during his career. At the same stage of their careers, the ten best players of 2015 had already collected 108 major titles, but Taylor alone accounted for 77 of those. Without the 16-time world champion, the other nine players from 2015 had won just 31 between them.
Lewis's generation, from around 2008 to 2016, featured an exceptional collection of world-class players. At the top was Phil Taylor, who won world titles in 2010 and 2013, and Michael van Gerwen, who made his breakthrough in 2012 and went on to dominate the sport for years. Behind them were Lewis himself, Gary Anderson, James Wade, Raymond van Barneveld, Simon Whitlock, Terry Jenkins, Wes Newton, Robert Thornton and, later, Peter Wright. A great example of that era's quality is the legendary semi-final between Taylor and Lewis at the 2013 Grand Slam of Darts, where both players averaged over 109 and together hit an incredible 32 maximums in just 25 legs. Taylor eventually won 16-9.
However, the picture becomes much more complicated when looking at the standard of the very best players today. Luke Littler has reached a level rarely seen before in a remarkably short time, with scoring power, consistent presence at major tournaments and an ability to keep producing high averages under pressure. Luke Humphries has shown he can consistently perform at an exceptionally high level. At just 19, Littler has already built an impressive collection of major titles, with 14 to his name as of 18 November 2026, and his ability to win matches with averages above 105 is exceptional. The current top ten have an average age of 34.90, compared with 39.70 in 2015, and according to the world rankings at the start of November 2026, Littler is top with more than £3 million, while Humphries and Van Veen each have around £1 million.
Lewis may have a stronger case when looking at the depth of the top ten. James Wade (7th) and Gary Anderson (16th) remain high in the world rankings despite their age, which speaks to their exceptional quality but also raises questions about the challenge posed by the younger generation. Yet the number of major titles does not prove that the competition was stronger fifteen years ago. The current generation, including players such as Littler and Gian van Veen, has had far fewer years on average to win major honours. In mid-November 2015, for example, Michael van Gerwen had won "only" eleven major titles. As for Lewis himself, he has not competed on the professional circuit since April 2023, with his last ranking title coming in July 2022, though he pointed to a recent exhibition match against Gary Anderson in which he averaged more than 112 as evidence he is far from finished. There is a big difference between an exhibition match and a full season on the PDC Tour, but a comeback would undoubtedly be interesting.